garonne: (Default)
garonne ([personal profile] garonne) wrote in [personal profile] regshoe 2020-06-15 07:57 pm (UTC)

This is so cool. And full of stuff I hadn't noticed. I never noticed Ewen being referred to as Captain Cameron for instance. Apparently I missed 14 instances of it :D

Also, I never noticed there was such a big difference in the choice of names in the narration when the POV changed, nor that there was such a difference, nor that there was such a change as the story progressed. I though those changes were mostly confined to the dialogue, not the narration, but clearly not!

Funnily enough I was just about to flick through FotH tonight trying to work out when and how exactly Keith switches from Mr Cameron to Ardroy, but I don't need to now *g* Basically I was wondering: if Keith were to write Ewen a letter after the events of the novel (assuming some AU where he could do so) then how would he begin the letter? I guess I can go with "Dear Ardroy".

After reading your post I flicked through GitN instead to see what I could spot there, and noticed that Archie calls Alison "Mrs Alison" instead of "Mrs Cameron", which I quite liked because someone (I think [personal profile] luzula?) mentioned that Scottish women at the time didn't necessarily change their names when they married, but Alison seems to end up being called Mrs Cameron a lot anyway.

(Although Archie's own wife is consistently referred to as Jean Cameron. But I think maybe she was already a Cameron before her marriage?)

Post a comment in response:

If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting