I still like "Kidnapped" better, but I think I appreciated "Catriona" more when I re-read it as a grown up, because 10 year old me found the first part (basically, when Alan still hasn't shown up) a bit dull XD But now I see it's a nicely crafted novel (and, no spoilers, but it offers possibilities for both m/m and f/f ships, which I really appreciate!)