End of year reading
The last few books of the year, plus a couple that I read for Yuletide reasons and hence didn't post about at the time. :)
Re-read Persuasion by Jane Austen (1817). Aww, this one was very well worth a re-read—one of my favourites by Austen, I think. I love Anne very much, and I enjoy the quiet and powerful longing of the developing relationship, and of course I love Sophia Croft and her husband very much too. I was also especially struck this time by the sense of a wider world beyond the limited social sphere of the immediate events, which all the naval characters and discussion of Navy life provide. Yeah, these books are actually set in the same world as the Hornblower novels, I can see it...
Irresolute Catherine by Violet Jacob (1908). This was a disappointment, I'm afraid! It's another one set in contemporary Wales; the title Catherine was engaged to one man, broke it off and later became engaged to another man, but at the time the book opens is still wavering between them. Although, to be fair to Jacob, the one Catherine ultimately chooses is less bad than the other, neither love interest is an especially good prospect—they're both possessively jealous in the really unappealing way, and both run roughshod over Catherine's 'irresoluteness'. Also I really disliked the way the important moment of Catherine's gaining the courage to make her own choices is inspired by a) a factually incorrect belief about one of her love interests treating her badly, instead of the various correct instances she could have come to recognise, b) jealousy of another woman who is described and treated by the narrative in decidedly unfeministical terms.
Cousin Phillis and Other Stories by Elizabeth Gaskell (written and originally published from 1850 to 1864; this collection published 2010). This was a bit of a puzzle; according to my reading log I read at least the novella 'Cousin Phillis' itself in 2016, but reading it again now I did not remember or recognise anything about it (and I can remember at least a little about all the other books I read around the same time and haven't re-read since). Is Gaskell particularly unmemorable? I wouldn't have thought so. No idea whether I read the other stories then too. Anyway, this is a collection of short stories plus one novella, mostly dealing with Gaskell's favourite theme of changes in society in the first half of the nineteenth century as experienced in the northwest of England, especially Manchester and its environs. I enjoyed them on the whole! One story is a sympathetic take on the problem of the unmarried mother, with interesting differences from the novel Ruth. A couple more, including 'Cousin Phillis', deal with women being jilted by men and subsequently remaining single; the men involved are too much Really Not Worth It to see the stories as especially tragic, but they're enjoyable, and the rural northwestern settings are very nice.
The Killing of the Red Fox: An Investigation into the Appin Murder by Seamus Carney (1989). Good readable account of the Appin murder and its surroundings. Much of the detail of the trial was not new to me, having already read the trial records, but Carney puts some things in context that I hadn't fully understood and adds a lot of interesting background material which was new to me (apart from having seen some of it in![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
muccamukk's meta posts!). Among other things, definite primary evidence for historical Allan Breck's age at the time of the murder being about thirty, the fact that at least one witness provably lied at the trial so as to incriminate Allan, and more thorough information about Allan's later life and French military career than anyone else seems to have turned up. (I have begun adding this to his Wikipedia article.) Having gone through the history, Carney summarises what other people have since written about the murder, calling Kidnapped 'an adventure yarn that will endure as long as the art of narrative'; he then gives his own judgements on the mystery, concluding that a) the shot was fired by Allan Breck and b) while it's not certain that James of the Glens wasn't involved, he probably wasn't, and the jury were certainly not justified in convicting him based on the available evidence; and finally sets out a speculative theory of exactly what happened, in which Allan Breck planned the murder in concert with James's eldest son Allan Beg Stewart and an unknown third man, without James's knowledge. So there you go.
And for Yuletide...
Superstitions of the Highlands and Islands of Scotland by John Gregorson Campbell (1900). Read as research for my supernatural Kidnapped story! Much of the book is about the fairies, and this gave me lots of good material, but I was enjoying it enough to continue onto the rest, which covers other superstitions such as the Glaistig (supernatural beings associated with particular places; I'm sure Ardroy has one) and the water-horse (my goodness, Highland water-horses are brutal! Brrr). Gregorson Campbell thoroughly disapproves of superstition, and occasionally gets sidetracked from the accounts of supernatural creatures and folktales to go on a digression explaining this to the reader; this made an entertaining contrast with Robert Kirk of The Secret Commonwealth, who believes what he's writing about.
And re-read Howards End by E. M. Forster (1910) Oh, I love this book. ♥ Characters, settings, themes, prose, all really wonderful. Of course I was canon-reviewing to write Margaret/Ruth femslash, so I especially paid attention to them, and I love them both and their relationship very much; I was also especially struck by Miss Avery, who so well understands what's going on and sees everything right in the end.
Re-read Persuasion by Jane Austen (1817). Aww, this one was very well worth a re-read—one of my favourites by Austen, I think. I love Anne very much, and I enjoy the quiet and powerful longing of the developing relationship, and of course I love Sophia Croft and her husband very much too. I was also especially struck this time by the sense of a wider world beyond the limited social sphere of the immediate events, which all the naval characters and discussion of Navy life provide. Yeah, these books are actually set in the same world as the Hornblower novels, I can see it...
Irresolute Catherine by Violet Jacob (1908). This was a disappointment, I'm afraid! It's another one set in contemporary Wales; the title Catherine was engaged to one man, broke it off and later became engaged to another man, but at the time the book opens is still wavering between them. Although, to be fair to Jacob, the one Catherine ultimately chooses is less bad than the other, neither love interest is an especially good prospect—they're both possessively jealous in the really unappealing way, and both run roughshod over Catherine's 'irresoluteness'. Also I really disliked the way the important moment of Catherine's gaining the courage to make her own choices is inspired by a) a factually incorrect belief about one of her love interests treating her badly, instead of the various correct instances she could have come to recognise, b) jealousy of another woman who is described and treated by the narrative in decidedly unfeministical terms.
Cousin Phillis and Other Stories by Elizabeth Gaskell (written and originally published from 1850 to 1864; this collection published 2010). This was a bit of a puzzle; according to my reading log I read at least the novella 'Cousin Phillis' itself in 2016, but reading it again now I did not remember or recognise anything about it (and I can remember at least a little about all the other books I read around the same time and haven't re-read since). Is Gaskell particularly unmemorable? I wouldn't have thought so. No idea whether I read the other stories then too. Anyway, this is a collection of short stories plus one novella, mostly dealing with Gaskell's favourite theme of changes in society in the first half of the nineteenth century as experienced in the northwest of England, especially Manchester and its environs. I enjoyed them on the whole! One story is a sympathetic take on the problem of the unmarried mother, with interesting differences from the novel Ruth. A couple more, including 'Cousin Phillis', deal with women being jilted by men and subsequently remaining single; the men involved are too much Really Not Worth It to see the stories as especially tragic, but they're enjoyable, and the rural northwestern settings are very nice.
The Killing of the Red Fox: An Investigation into the Appin Murder by Seamus Carney (1989). Good readable account of the Appin murder and its surroundings. Much of the detail of the trial was not new to me, having already read the trial records, but Carney puts some things in context that I hadn't fully understood and adds a lot of interesting background material which was new to me (apart from having seen some of it in
muccamukk's meta posts!). Among other things, definite primary evidence for historical Allan Breck's age at the time of the murder being about thirty, the fact that at least one witness provably lied at the trial so as to incriminate Allan, and more thorough information about Allan's later life and French military career than anyone else seems to have turned up. (I have begun adding this to his Wikipedia article.) Having gone through the history, Carney summarises what other people have since written about the murder, calling Kidnapped 'an adventure yarn that will endure as long as the art of narrative'; he then gives his own judgements on the mystery, concluding that a) the shot was fired by Allan Breck and b) while it's not certain that James of the Glens wasn't involved, he probably wasn't, and the jury were certainly not justified in convicting him based on the available evidence; and finally sets out a speculative theory of exactly what happened, in which Allan Breck planned the murder in concert with James's eldest son Allan Beg Stewart and an unknown third man, without James's knowledge. So there you go.And for Yuletide...
Superstitions of the Highlands and Islands of Scotland by John Gregorson Campbell (1900). Read as research for my supernatural Kidnapped story! Much of the book is about the fairies, and this gave me lots of good material, but I was enjoying it enough to continue onto the rest, which covers other superstitions such as the Glaistig (supernatural beings associated with particular places; I'm sure Ardroy has one) and the water-horse (my goodness, Highland water-horses are brutal! Brrr). Gregorson Campbell thoroughly disapproves of superstition, and occasionally gets sidetracked from the accounts of supernatural creatures and folktales to go on a digression explaining this to the reader; this made an entertaining contrast with Robert Kirk of The Secret Commonwealth, who believes what he's writing about.
And re-read Howards End by E. M. Forster (1910) Oh, I love this book. ♥ Characters, settings, themes, prose, all really wonderful. Of course I was canon-reviewing to write Margaret/Ruth femslash, so I especially paid attention to them, and I love them both and their relationship very much; I was also especially struck by Miss Avery, who so well understands what's going on and sees everything right in the end.
no subject
I'm glad someone finally actually read all of Murder of the Red Fox. Though I remain sceptical that there's proof one way or another who fired the shot. Bless you for updating Allan's terrible wiki page.
no subject
I am also sceptical (although possibly biassed by my love for the fictional Alan). As for the wiki page, possibly some of the remaining history stuff is slightly dodgy, but I have at least added a section about Kidnapped. :D
no subject
I really ought to return to my Jane Austen reread! And the E. M. Forster reread (first read for a few of his books) that I've vaguely planned but never started. In high school I wrote a term paper about Howards End, which I loved, but I haven't revisited the book since then.
no subject
Austen and Forster are both well worth re-reading! Hmm, perhaps I should re-read Northanger Abbey next, I remember it's great fun.
no subject
no subject
I've ogled the Gregorson Campbell book several times in Waterstones, but have so far managed to resist the temptation, mostly on the grounds of having no shelf space. I'll cave in one day, though. XD Care to expand on your Ardroy glaistig theory, or is it just a feeling? It definitely seems like a place that should have its own sympathetic spirit. :D
no subject
If you do ebooks, there is a free one on Gutenberg!
Well, given Ewen's deep love for and connection to the land, it would only be fitting for there to be some spirit watching over Ardroy and looking out for him. :) And it could interact interestingly with Ewen's views on the supernatural—he's sceptical in canon, being an educated gentleman, but perhaps there have been a few times when someone seemed to be looking out for the cattle... I'm sure she'd be friends with the heron, too.
(Incidentally, the first example of a Glaistig that Gregorson Campbell gives is the one attached to the house of Auchindarroch in Glen Duror, where James of the Glens lived until Colin the Fox kicked him out, and hence where Al(l)an grew up!)
no subject
The supernatural Scotland one sounds quite entertaining.
no subject
Very entertaining, and I'm sure it'll continue to be a rich source of inspiration for Kidnapped and Flight of the Heron fic...
no subject
Oh, it's a pity about the Jacobs book--she seems bit more uneven than Broster. Well, I'll know to steer away from that one, then.
I know that I have also forgotten having read a Gaskell book, and fittingly I have also now forgotten which one it was. Possibly North and South?
Thanks for the folklore book; that one will be useful when I get to my fairy tale FotH AU.
no subject
I do remember North and South, although it's not my favourite by her (that's Wives and Daughters, which has a charming naturalist love interest—you might like it!).
Thanks for the folklore book; that one will be useful when I get to my fairy tale FotH AU.
:)